Skip to content
Pickering Plumbing Company markPickeringPlumbing Co.Call now(365) 334-6645

Ledger note ยท Hot water

Renting vs Purchasing a Water Heater in Ontario

Water heater rentals are common across Ontario, and many Pickering homes have one. Whether to keep renting or buy depends on the contract, the tank and your plans.

  • About 2 minutes to read
  • Best timing: any time of year
  • Tools: a flashlight and a notebook
  • Written for homeowners, not trades
Call now(365) 334-6645

A plumber answers.
No forms, no waiting list.

Bright and modern interior of a home with wooden floors and staircase
Bright and modern interior of a home with wooden floors and staircase.

Open 7 daysEmergencies any hour

  • Licensed plumbers, details on request
  • Quote before any work starts
  • Pickering and Durham Region
  • Residential and commercial

The routine, in order

  1. Find the agreement. Look for the rental firms name on the tank sticker and request a copy of the contract.
  2. Check the tank's age. The build date is usually hidden in the serial number.
  3. Get the buyout figure. Call the rental company and ask for the current buyout cost in writing.
  4. Compare totals. Add up what you would pay renting for the next several years versus buying a new unit or the existing one.
  5. Consider your plans. If you will move soon, the comparison shifts.
  6. Consider alternatives. Tankless or higher-efficiency tanks may suit your home better if you are replacing anyway.
  7. Arrange removal. If ending a rental, confirm how the rental company will collect its tank.

Why this matters in Pickering

Many Pickering homes were built with rental water heaters, and owners often inherit the contract when they buy a house. Monthly fees continue for years, sometimes long after the tank's value has been paid many times over. Buyout terms vary widely between providers, and some contracts include notice periods, removal charges and restrictions. Understanding the agreement helps you decide.

Call when the tank is leaking, giving no hot water, rumbling loudly or more than ten to twelve years old.

Slips worth avoiding

  • Signing a new rental agreement at the door without reading the terms. Door-to-door sales for water heaters have drawn consumer complaints in Ontario.
  • Assuming a rental always includes free repairs. Check what maintenance is covered.
  • Throwing out the rental tank. It belongs to the rental company.
  • Forgetting the notice-of-security-interest that some rental companies register on the home, which can complicate a sale.
Bench note: Ontario consumer protection rules include a cooling-off period for agreements signed at your door. If you were pressured into a contract, look into your options promptly.

Time to ring a plumber

Call when the tank is leaking, giving no hot water, rumbling loudly or more than ten to twelve years old. If you own it, we can repair or replace it. If you rent it, contact the rental company first for covered repairs. When you decide to switch to an owned unit, we can install one and leave the rental tank ready for collection.

Reading the numbers calmly

Write down three figures: the monthly rental fee, the current buyout amount and an installed price for a comparable owned tank. Multiply the rental fee by the number of years you expect to stay. The comparison is usually clear on paper, though maintenance coverage and your comfort with handling repairs also matter. If you are weighing a different type of heater, see our tank versus tankless note. While you are reviewing household equipment, a worn toilet flapper is another quiet cost; our toilet repair page explains the fix. Keep every letter from the rental company in one folder.

Whichever way you decide, put a reminder in your calendar to drain a little water from the tank once a year to clear sediment.

Questions callers ask

How long do tank water heaters last?

Eight to twelve years is typical, with water quality and upkeep tipping it either way.

Can I cancel a water heater rental any time?

Contracts differ. Some require a buyout, others a removal fee. Read the terms or ask the company.

Related pages

Call (365) 334-6645